“Ultimately, a man should not ask what the meaning of his life is, but rather must recognize that it is he who is asked. Each man is questioned by life; and he can only answer to life by answering for his own life; to life he can only respond by being responsible.”
This quote was my first introduction to Viktor Frankl in Stephen Covey’s famous book “The Seven Habits of highly effective people”. It was amazing to read about a person who could emerge a better man from the hopelessness of the Nazi Concentration Camp. In the midst of starvation and brutality he could conceptualize a new school of psychotherapy called Logotherapy and went on to cure many people. Logotherapy works on the premise that many of our mental and even physical illness is because we don’t see any meaning to our lives. It tries to find a cure to these illnesses by helping people find a meaning to their life.
This week, I read his book “Man’s search for meaning”. It is about his experiences in a Nazi concentration camp called Auschwitz. In addition, the book also gives an overview of Logotherapy in his own words. He is not a skilled writer but there is something so honest about his words that they touch you. There are so many poignant moments in the book.
His terrible misery at having to give-up the manuscript of his book until he discovered that he was wearing the coat of a man who was sent to the gas chambers. In the pocket there was a single page which contained a Hebrew prayer.
Although you have heard countless stories of holocaust, this story still shocks you. People were sorted based on their physical fitness to decide if they should be sent directly to the gas chambers. They had to work for long hours in the cold without adequate protection or food. A grown up man cried like a child when his shoes wore out and he had to walk bare foot in biting cold to work in the field. People were reduced to animals, doing anything for self-preservation. He even talks about cannibalism; people eating body parts of corpses. The worse of these were people who gave up hope. They used to lie in their own urine and excreta and refuse to move whatever the threat. Such people died within a few days.
Frankl asks the question “Does man have no choice of action in face of such circumstances.” And he answers, “The experience of camp life show that a man does have a choice of action… We who lived in concentration camp can remember men who walked through the huts comforting others, giving away their last piece of bread. They may have been few in number, but they offer sufficient proof that everything can be taken from a man but one thing; the last of human freedoms – to choose ones attitude in any given set of circumstances, to choose ones own way”
Frankl recalls a young women whom he met in the camp, who knew she would die in the next few days. Yet, she was cheerful. She said to him “I am glad that fate has hit me so hard. In my former life I was spoiled and did not take spiritual accomplishments seriously.” He says there is meaning to every life and it is unique to each one of us. He recalls a man who made a pact with god. He would bear all the suffering in exchange for the life of his loved ones. From that moment on even his suffering had a deep meaning for him.
Frankl Concludes, “Man is ultimately self-determining. What he becomes he has made out of himself. In the concentration camp we watched and witnessed some of our comrades behave like swine while others behave like saints. Man has both potentialities within himself; what he becomes depends on his decisions not on conditions.
Afterall, man is that being who invented the gas chambers of Auschwitz; however he is also that being who entered those chambers upright with lord’s prayers on his lips.”
Great post Archana! Many times I really don’t understand the meaning of life and just lead my life blindly.
Having a meaning makes even makes a “difficult” life easy. Frankl thoughts are really good. Ultimately I think all of us live our lives searching and finding a meaning to it.
Nice post Archana. You may also want to look up the stockdale paradox in Jim Collins’s good to great book
Thank you, Saraswathi. Its a book worth reading, do look it up when you find time.
Thank you Sukumar. I just looked up the stockdale paradox and I was stuck by how startlingly similar it was to the Frankl’s experience.
He says the death toll increased during Christmas, because who harbored the false hope that they were going to be released by Christmas felt bitterly disappointed when it did not happen.
He says that ultimately they may not escape death but the feeling that there is a meaning even to this suffering and death kept people healthy. He talks about how he rewrote the lost manuscript of his book on scraps of paper, even though he may never see it published, it gave him a purpose.
Thanks for the pointer. it was a good read.
Nice post there Archana!
Sometimes, I cant reconcile myself to the fact of this line of thinking somehow, that man has to answer n not ask. If it is who is being asked, that means v rnt the master but the slave answering the master! Does that mean v have no way to live our life but answer things posed by circumstances? :S
Thanks Naresh. I think the intent of the quote is different. It does not imply that you are a victim of circumstances. It just says, what ever you circumstances you can find a meaning and purpose to your life. Whether your are a garbage collector or a jew in a brutal concentration camp, you can make your life worthwhile by choosing your attitude.
All it means is don’t question life “why me?”, instead question yourself “why me”, may be because it something only I can do.
Hi Archana,
Awesome post.Thanks for sharing this sensible post with us all!
I basically love philosophy and love philosophizing.I really look forward to reading the book.I’d also like to suggest something;
Read books by Jostein Gaarder.His works are basically in Norwegian but have been translated.He’ s one awesome guy to look out for,in this genre.But his works are entirely different.They might sound like fairy tales but the moment you read the lines,you never know you have started “thinking”.
I have not raed non fictions or novels taht are purely philosophical,would love to do so in the future!Thanks for the mention,anyways.
Thank you, Ranjini. Glad you liked it. I will see if Jostein Gaarder translations are available here at Chennai. Can you recommend a title.
If you are planning on philosophical / self help books, I would definitely recommend 7 habits. I think, it is the best in the genre
Hi Archana ,
I got to your blog from Niranjan’s and I was reading your posts for quite sometime and its well written. I would like to tag you in my blog if you say YES. Pls have a look if u need to and you can say ur YES there in the latest post
Regards ,
InvisibleChina
[...] 22nd, 2007 by archanaraghuram I had written a review of “Man’s search for meaning” last week. My friend and CKO of my company, Sukumar had commented that I should look up The [...]
Try Jostein gaarder’s “Sophie’s world” and “the solitaire mystery”.They are the best.Ofcourse,i haven’t tried all his other works .don’t think they are available here.But u had better buy them!
Never heard of 7 habits.will try to get it.Is it a series kind of thing like chicken soup?
Regards,
ranjani R
I would rate, 7 Habits as the best book on self improvement ever. It is not like Chicken Soup (which is just a collection of stories)
Nice post. Despair can douse u into an abyss; Frankl et al have dived deep into that abyss and have come away smiling. They emerged with an embarrassing bliss that humbles the human within us. Also can look up Elie Wiesel (b.1928)
Thank you, Tatvva. I just looked up Elie Wiesel in Wikipedia. Wow, there are so many great people whom we have not heard of. Thanks for the pointer.
Meaning of life in the extreme situations like the one mentioned in the post is hard to decide. But for the others like us, it should not be so hard. Meaning of life is enjoying the life. But the only problem is nobody knows what needs to be done to achieve enjoyment. That is where we need research. Those research reports are philosophies. Budha said give up obsession. Christ said love neighbours and many other saints said a set of solutions. But the problem is none of these solutions are 100% practical. That is where you find the greatness of indian philosophy which is not just a set of rules by which human beings live. It by itself is a living style where you do not have to take conscious effort to live a meaningful life.
Basic idea of life is to execute dharma. But without thinking of its result. Just think of a painter who is getting ready to draw his master piece. The first thing he does is getting ready mentally and physically. determination. clear mind. It is like Krishna asking arjuna to give up depressed mental state and get to work. Arjuna gets ready to execute his dharma of his time. Now he is not going to think about any result. Painter keeps doing his work without complaints or greed. Karma. Ultimately once he finishes the work, he give up all Karma that he has done, any brushes or paints. Forgets all pain. He is now filled with the joy beholding the portrait.
Likewise anyone like us must execute dharma set for our time without obsession of the result. It all works out in the mind. When you have obsession, brain is controlled by certain negative hormones which causes all bad moods. When you are free from obsessions, your mind becomes as thin as air. Now you enjoy a kind of freedom. Positiveness. You then start seeing the world, people, flowers and everything in this beautiful world which are created for us to enjoy.
With this mind execute karma. after each karma you will gradually get notification of your next karma from The Mighty Unknown. (The last statement can be criticized), but that requires experience to understand. Observe things in life, experiment things in life like Gandhiji did. We can observe the repeatability of the effectiveness of prayers, wills and celebacy and many other actions we do in life. Like how prayer affects, whether if has any effect or which kind of prayer is more effective like that. That itself is a great research.
In a nutshell, all who are weeping about the meaning of life are like arjuna. Most of them seems to be youngsters with kids, in their 30s. Managing kids is the biggest trouble. On top of that work related and other issues. You cannot sit down and write a poem. We shall sure think what life is this. But ask any old person if life has any meaning, he/she shall have a lot to say about a meaningful life. We will eventually understand the meaning by experience. It is like smelling a rose flower. You can read about it, write about it, hear about it, but until you actually smell it, you won’t know its fragrance.
Regards
Biju
Thanks for those insights, Biju. You seem to be a deeply spiritual person.
CENTERBRIDGEBOOKS
Amazing writing! Maria
[...] Raghuram’s excellent post on Man’s search for Meaning and her follow up post on the Stockdale Paradox gave me the impetus to write this [...]
I like this post. I recently read this book as well and wrote an interpretation of how to find meaning based on this book and God.
Check it out on my site:
http://www.graceforgrace.com